Commerzbank Battles UniCredit’s Narrative With Shock Tender Breakdown: Banks, Not Holders, Bolstered Bid

Bettina Orlopp, chief executive of Commerzbank, fired a final salvo at UniCredit’s takeover approach this week, releasing a detailed breakdown of who actually tendered shares during the regular offer period. The numbers paint a stark picture for the Italian lender. Of the 12.51% acceptance rate recorded by UniCredit on June 19, a full 11.17 percentage points came from banks – mostly institutions acting as derivative counterparties linked to UniCredit itself. Retail investors accounted for just 0.05 percentage points, and other institutional holders contributed 1.29 points. In aggregate, less than 1% of Commerzbank’s more than 500,000 private shareholders and several hundred independent institutional investors bothered to accept the bid.

That reality stands in sharp contrast to UniCredit’s headline figure. The Milan-based bank reported an aggregated position of 42.50% when combining its existing 26.77% stake, the 12.51% of tendered shares, and a further 3.22% from instruments with physical delivery rights. Two readings of the same data set are now competing for investor attention. UniCredit frames the numbers as evidence of growing control; Commerzbank counters that the overwhelming majority of genuine, arm’s-length shareholders have rejected the offer outright.

Orlopp drove the point home in a letter to shareholders on June 26, urging them to ignore the extended deadline and retain their holdings. The regular acceptance period closed on June 16, but a further acceptance window runs until July 3. UniCredit is actively soliciting tenders during that window, though it cannot change the terms of the offer. The final result is scheduled for publication on July 8.

Should investors sell immediately? Or is it worth buying Commerzbank?

Market reaction to the standoff has been muted. Commerzbank shares closed at €37.68 on Friday, a gain of 0.35% on the day, leaving them roughly 3% below the 52-week high of €38.85 set on June 19. The stock has slipped 1.70% over the past seven days, suggesting a pause after the spike that followed UniCredit’s initial disclosure of the aggregated stake. Both the 50-day and 200-day moving averages sit comfortably below the current price, keeping the technical picture constructive for now.

Orlopp has pointed to the bank’s first-quarter 2026 results as evidence that a standalone strategy is viable. Commerzbank reported an operating profit of €1.4 billion and net income of €913 million for the period, with a full-year net target of at least €3.4 billion. The second-quarter earnings, due on August 6, will provide the next operational benchmark – and Orlopp has already framed that date as a chance to demonstrate momentum without UniCredit’s involvement.

With the extended deadline approaching, the key question is whether any additional retail or institutional holders will break ranks before July 3. UniCredit needs broad-based acceptance to convert its arithmetic stake into effective control. Commerzbank is betting that the near-total boycott so far – just 0.05% from retail, 1% from independent investors – will hold. The next few days will determine whether the Italian bank’s 42.50% claim is a prelude to dominance or a paper victory that dwindles under scrutiny.

Ad

Commerzbank Stock: New Analysis - 27 June

Fresh Commerzbank information released. What's the impact for investors? Our latest independent report examines recent figures and market trends.

Read our updated Commerzbank analysis...

en | DE000CBK1001 | COMMERZBANK | boerse | 69639300 |